Since the beginning of time free thinking can be define as anyone who did not conform to status qua-wherever was social, political or any kind though outside, like Jews refusing to accept Christianity or Islam prescription of the Messiah or political moments from the right or left in19 century. The Blog follows the spirit of Spinoza which challenge not only his own Hebrew roots, but also Christianity with the tolerance of Montaigne. We dedicate this blog to all them were burn for dare to ask.
Monday, January 01, 2018
A case for Europe
Hannah Arendt in The Origins of Totalitarianism makes an argument the
Antisemitism is a product of the 18 Century of the Industrial and Mercantilism,
since the Jews stop serving usefulness to the elite, since 429 (began in March
26, 429 and published in February 15 430) with the codification Theodosian Code
denying the Jews any land ownership, in Poland for example, Casimir IV the
Jagiellonian (1447–1492) retracted the right to work the land.
While historical they are two documents of Anti-Semitism, in the
Elephantine Papyri consist of 175 documents from the Egyptian border fortresses
of Elephantine and Syene (Aswan), besides of individual Jewish family saga (Ananiah
and Tamut), but the request to rebuild the Jewish Temple in the Island destroy in
a Pogrom early, the request when to the Persian governor of Judea, appealing
for assistance in rebuilding the Jewish temple:
“Now our forefathers built this temple in the fortress of Elephantine
back in the days of the kingdom of Egypt, and when Cambyses came to Egypt he
found it built. They knocked down all the temples of the gods of Egypt, but no
one did any damage to this temple”
The request also when to Sanballat I, a Samaritan potentate, and his
sons Delaiah and Shelemiah, as well as Johanan ben Eliashi, mention in Nehemiah
2:19 and 12:33
They gave a positive respond:
There was a response of both governors (Bagoas and Delaiah) which gave
the permission by decree to rebuild the temple written in the form of a
memorandum:
“Memorandum of what Bagohi and Delaiah said to me, saying: Memorandum:
You may say in Egypt ... to build it on its site as it was formerly..."
Moreover, after the Jewish revolt in 70 AD, Rome transforming Jerusalem
to Aelia Capitolina (Jerusalem was
dedicated to Jupiter Capitolinus in the site of the Jewish Temple) to 638 AD
the date was conquer by the Arabs. Hadrian had the determination to deny any
claim to the Jewish included Judea in Syria-Palestinian province.
The second instance Alexandria 38 BEC, in the Monotheist cults
(Christianity and Islam) the Jews was the other (see The Historical Origin of
antisemitism, Israelowitz 2016, Gustav Landauer Press), with Constantine make
Christianity the official Religion of the Empire, Christianity was in direct competition
and later on Islam about the ownership to God.
Napoleon understood the Europe was found on this Mythology, to brake
with his Secular Empire, his creation gave for the first time the Jews a
citizenship, where being a Jews is normal not the outsider (see Richard J
Evans, The Pursuit of Power, Europe 1815-1915, 2016, Allen Lane an imprint of
Penguin Books), the caricature created Hadrian, Christianity (no more a courses
for not accepted the Christian Messiah) and Islam (by not accepting the
Prophet, while the Dimmi laws was not unique toward the Jews included the
Christians, the different was the Islam
saw the Jews more weak, where Christianity had back of Armies who fought
Islam).
Napoleon defeated by the British and holy Alliance of the Czar and Austria,
a reactionary, since Frank Jesseph and The Czar believed in Autocratic
authority, the British tolerated, since their Empire was commerce, and the
their despotic was not only to maintain power as the case of Austria and
Russia, but commerce.
After the Lithuanian-Polish Commonwealth, weaken by the Sweden, and Sweden
lost the territory to Russia, Katheryn (the German Princes now the Czarina of
Russia), the territory where the Jews inhabited the Pale (the region was from
Odessa to middle of Latvia), she confined to territory, not Jews were allot to inhabitant
Moscow.
In the transition period (there was a total of three partitions, the first
with Prussia in 1772 losing 30% of the territory, the second partition was in
1790, Poland form a nation supported by Prussia, Prussia interest was a buffer
to Russia, eventually abandoned in 1795 the thirs partition Poland lost Russia gain 1 Million and 120,000 Km square,
Prussia 55,000 Km square and Austria 47,000 Km square, Poland is political
identity stop to exist), in the disintegration of the Commonwealth the Poles
fought the Russians their distinct culture and Religion, different from
Orthodox Russia, the Rabbis of the fourth lands needed to decided which site to
take, in the end the Jews cannot find common front, some fought with the Poles
against the Russians, others submitted to Russian Rules, the internal disagreement,
was Catholic Poland foster an Anti-Semitisms in the every day, while the
Russian still was unknown, in the long run Russia rule driven by Rusification
was harsh to everyone, the Lithuanian for 100 years can never speak their own language,
Ukraine suffer a cultural Genocide, in
Poland the Universities were closed, for the Jews the Czar obligated the
communities to give 3 of their sons to the Military, while for the Russian the
Military was 3 years conscript, for the Jews was 10 years, because the Jews
began to Marry their son at 13 Years old, Russia impose the legal age at 12, in
the end with Czar Secret Police created one of the must Anti-Semitic books The
Protocols of the Elders of Zion written in 1903, which fuel Antisemitism in
Europe to new highs.
The 19 Century Antisemitism was secularization open pseudo sciences and
pseudo occult theories (see Goodrick Clarke The Occults Roots of , 2004 and
Aryan Cults, Esoteric Nazism and the Politics of Identity, Black Sun, 2003),
Richard J Evans in The Third Reich in History and Memory, 2015, Little Brown,
discuss the German Empire using Industrial Genocide in the Namibia Colony (specially
introduction of Concentration Camps) and introduction of Racial laws in Rwanda
all this early 1900´s while the first Industrial (scale terror) was carry by
Leopold II in the Congo, included the French in Algiers in 1870´s while was
terror in Industrial scale.
Arendt provided the inside of the Epistemology of Industrial mass
killing, previously the conflict between power of Islam, by invaded Spain, and occupied
Spain from 792 to 1492 (does not included the Alpujarras revolt 1568–1571, two
Kings crowned during the revolt), the Battle of Lepanto, Venice stop Islam in
Lepanto, but the Stopping of Turks in Vienna twice stop any more claims of
Islam or dreams towards Europe (see Weatcroft, Infidels A History of Conflict
between Christendom and Islam, 2003 Penguin; The Enemy at the Gate, 2008 Basic Books; The Ottomans Dissolved
Images, 1993 Penguin Books—Karsh Islamic Imperialism A History 2007 Yale
University Press).
Half of the 20th century, WWI brought Industrial Killing in Military
and WWII Industrial Killing included civilians (see Ian Kershaw to Hell And
Back Europe 1914-1949, 2015Penguin Books), while the first Industrial genocide
carry by the Ottomans, to the Armenians in WWI closed to 1.5 Million (the
analysis refere to 800,00), (Schaller,
Dominik J; Zimmerer, Jürgen 2008. Late Ottoman genocides: the dissolution of
the Ottoman Empire and Young Turkish population and extermination policies –
introduction". Journal of Genocide Research. 10 (1): 7–14,
doi:10.1080/14623520801950820; Ferguson, Niall , 2006. The War of the World:
Twentieth-Century Conflict and the Descent of the West. New York: Penguin Press.
p. 177). The absolutism of Austria and Russia monarchies become the seeds of
WWI, Franz refusal of Serbs freedom recent in the Slaves in Balkans or Russian
Czar give the freedom to Serbs (See Evans, The Pursuit of Power, Europe 1815-1915, 2016, Allen Lane an imprint of
Penguin Books), but carry a despotic absolutism, open doors to Russian
Revolution
Primo Levi described when he arrive to Auschwitz, when the Number was tattoo
he was not a person he was the Medieval Jew not a person, but there was no-more
Medieval Jews under Theodosian Code, he was not a person, the Christian
Nihilism of Europe, while Europe identity (this should include Islam) was
defined in the Antisemitism, the US of America was defined by race (while
slaves was part of Antiquated, Islam—the innovation as mention in Arendt, Race
become the reason entree to justify Slave system, see Parkinson The common
cause, Creating Race and the Nation in the America Revolution, 2016, The University
North Carolina Pres; Johson and Smith Africans in American, 1998 A Harvest Book,
Hardcourt Brace & Company), for 500
years of institutionalism (Hugh Thomas, The Slave Trade, The story of the
Atlantic Slave Trade 1440-1870, 1997, Simon & Schuster; Wilder, Ebony &
Ivy Race, Slavery and Troubled History of America´s Universities, 2013
Bloomsbury Press) .
Europe born of the Ashes from Civilian Genocide, in some level Fascism
with Corporate state (Mussolini said he was Anti-Semitic before Hitler mention
in a letter to his mistress Clara Petacci, Bosworth Mussolini´s Italy Life
under Dictatorship, 1915-1945, 2006 penguin), Salazar (Estado Novo—one required
for the economy to function the need of colonies to provide the raw materials
and the state to produce the consumer products) in Portugal put in motion this
theory in the must pure form, the inertia of the Bureaucracy stop the economy
in his tracks, the same when with Franco.
The corporate state was Roman Catholic alternative answer to Socialism,
aware of the inequality from Pope Leo XIII (1887-1903)respond against socialism
was negative to the idea Socialism rejected Private property his alternative
Corporate economy where the workers, state and owners
negotiated for the benefice.
For Germany the Utopia for his corporate state was cult of race and the
other was the Jews. Independent of the emotional manipulation the continue
economic conflict between France and Germany due to coal production, after WWII
in 1951 creation of European Coal and
Steel Community, propose by French foreign minister Robert Schuman on 9 May
1950 as a way to prevent further war between France and Germany.
Russia revolt against the despotic autocratic Czar, created a centralize
authority (in some ways the Lenin transfer the power from Autocratic Czar to the
Autocratic state—directorship of the Czar to the working class, Dostoyevsky in
Crime Punishment the Moral Power (The Social definition of Behavior different
from Individual Behavior: Morality is the codes and values which we live by (https://drwilliamlarge.wordpress.com/2012/10/21/on-the-difference-between-ethics-and-morality-lecture-2/),
where ethics is the individual choice ). The Czar had authority given from divined—in
Lenin/Marx case the moral authority was from the toil and exploitation of the
majority who created the wealth for the few—the working class) ), which take
the backward to an industrialized nation, but because the same reason saw a limitation,
which limited their own revolution only to Russia (see Kershaw To Hell and Back
Europe 1914-1949).
The clear failure show twice in Spain in 1936 the Spanish revolution,
the first is Kerwshaw described the Communist did to have tolerance towards decent
(Orwell, Homage to Catalonia, 1952 Harcourt, Brace & World, Inc New York; Hugh
Thomas, The Spanish Civil War Eyre & Spottiswode (Publishers) LTD; Beevor
Antony, The Battle for Span The Spanish Civil War 1936-1939, 1982 Phoenix; Leval
Gaston, Colectividades Libertarias En Espana, 1977 Editorial Aguilera—Madrid; Marin Dolores, Anarquistas Un Siglo De
Movimiento Libertario En Espana, 2010, Ariel). Despite Franco not just
sympathies with Hitler cause in the name of Fascism, passive/active work for
Hitler cause, not repercussions, with the exception Spain was isolated, in part
because Stalin abandoned Communist in Spain to maintain his sphere influence in
Eastern Europe, for political Expediency, as Orwell disillusion with Centralize
Left—the Communist Party in Spain, in Animal Farm, some Animals are more equal
than others.
Russia taken a different direction the Socialism, force collectivization
in Ukraine and center on Russia, not other voices as Hungary, Czechoslovakia
and Poland found out, the Soviet was Russia Socialisms, Russia fear of the
Marshal plant, since Czechoslovakia and Poland were very receipted Russia wanted
to maintain sphere influence a buffer to the west. Russia created COMECON (Council
for Mutual Economic Assistance—1949) to contra balance the economics of the
West, with great growth of Russia in the 1950´s all become to stop due to the
Centralized economic development in COMECON and reality was subside Russia, the
economic inertia finally taken effect in 1980´s, with the end of Soviet empire.
The west driven had not to do with economics but the continue blood of
for last 2000 years culminated with the Genocide of the Civilian population.
Today Europe is in Crises in some ways from external and Internal, while
the solution already on hand.
Russia after the collapse of the Soviet Union, have reduced his economy to
evolved to corporate state based on a kleptocracy
and the Imperialist dreams of sphere of influence, for Eastern Europe the 75
Years of Imperial Soviet do not want to do with Russia, on the other had US
model of few haven the wealth, and free for all lazier economic system, in 2008
economic meltdown, begin between a collusion between the Banks and rate
agencies, given triple A, hypothetic, praying on the current interpretation
wealth base on house ownership, but given credit to people could not maintain the
cost, many of this companies come to low middle class, minorities to equivalence
of renting to home ownership, without tell them extra cost. When the self-fulling
economic prophesy burst the economic model, the US banks having a foot in
Europe through London, sold Europe junk bonds, where some self-contain
economies Ireland and Spain had their own House Bubble, but since credit become
scare, limited the credit for rest influence included the bond credit for Greece,
Documentary Inside Job by Charles Ferguson, show the Mechanism, the failure,
complicated, historical the idea of Private property was based on exclusivity given by the structure who hold power (see
Proudhon What is property; Carso Kevin Studies in Mutualist Political Economy,
2004 Fayetteville Ark), in other words the legitimation only through the
structure.
The economic alienation produce populisms, historically populisms in the
working class with exception in Spain (at most part), the left, but In Europe
has been to the right with the consequence of US actions in Iraq resulting
un-stability in Syria and the rise of the Islamic state, Anti immigrants and
fear of Islam imposed by population in US the rise is Economic Nationalism,
given by the same elites and party who sold illusion of trickle down economy,
the three states in US which follow are economic bankrupt, Kansas, Oklahoma and
North Caroline, lowing the taxes does not increase wages—after all the cost
production is fix, does not create more jobs, if there is not demand cannot
bring more jobs, and automatization will increased if production can be better
or more , with less workers cost is less, since in the Capitalist system the
collection of individuals make macro, does not care the macro, the consequence
as stand now is unemployment, limiting access education and health system a
cost.
The irony in US the Economic Nationalism is run by someone who bankrupt
itself six times, avoid the draft fourth times, never pay their contactors, the
bank loans or their employers in minimal, and exploit illegal immigrants.
The reaction to Europe populism is many of them, see the benefit of
internal open borders, Erasmus is education tool, even Hungary due fact small
country cannot be economically independent, moreover in Germany every street there
is Holocaust, France with immigrant issues does remember the cost of Nationalism,
Easter Europe the Russian occupation, despite all the machinations towards
Ukraine, Russia Imperialism and Russia never expect Ukrainian population will
stand, many see their economic development model to Poland.
The British exit of EU open doors for better integration, but the ethnic’s
identities and Centralized bureaucracy. Europe has a historical model the
canton of the Swiss Federations, Europe have the mechanism to transform
itself libertarian (left), the Mechanism exits: The Council of European
Municipalities (http://www.ccre.org) and European Councils (http://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/european-council/),
the Federation consist of 150,000 regions a total 41 countries, the Bologna
need to discard and return local higher
education, to transform and increase to open Universities—Popular Schools—Popular
Universities, the system was developed according to pay for fee Anglo-Saxon
system, which UK is not part of EU,
their need not need to consider.
The welfare should be independent work driven similar to Denmark model.
Germany economy is based on medium and family production, why not encourage
cooperatives, since us passing to a pots-scarcity economy, where Artesian and
individualism economy, haven a Minimal Salary, to open doors to new ideas, for
individuals experiments and created.
Brookchin in Post-Scarcity Anarchism and some extend Gustav Landauer
gave political and economic Models, the Kurds in Rojava are applying this
model, with this model, while Cataluna cannot be independent from Spain, can be
independent in Spain, European Union will not disappear, will make more
adaptive and open—individual communities can respond to their individual needs,
despite the nationalism dreams the borders are open, information cannot be
control will leak in one way on other, wealth can be transfer touch of a button,
crypto currencies will make harder to stop, with 3-D printers a product can be
produce in your own house, manufacture become individualist. European Union can
be the umbrella where all this experiment is occurring making life better for
everyone.
The climate change is forcing us to turn to sustainable green
technologies, solar, wind biogas, electrical cars, electrical plane are here to
stay and development cannot be stop, a change where the economics, education
where with a computer system classes can be taken, information can be published
anyone with the same interest have access, an open society, even with
disinformation, reality, movement of life cannot be stop.
Sunday, December 03, 2017
A question of Science
Science is a
complicated process of understanding in some many levels—they are two basic
questions needs to be answer. The first is a control and second can the
prediction can be replicated. There is a misunderstanding—a mythology, the idea
between hard science and soft science, where each disciplined required
different levels of understanding and required different set of skills.
While, a model—predictions
need to consider only what replications say, will be very disingenuous to force
a replication, to fit a model, and the skills—understanding are different. There
is no such thing one body of knowledge is better than other, each level of understanding
given a better perception of our surrounding.
Mathematics
dependent on the logic able to maintain an internal consistence—if not a misunderstanding,
on the other hand, other understanding—epistemology dependents ideal of a
simplicity or universal understanding others really dependents, because the
complexity where the question, then complex understanding required.
How a body of knowledge
is created, how the knowledge become its own identity. Many factors, one when a
questions needs to be dedicated their own set of understanding, when the
question born from other analysis, cannot be answer by previous knowledge, and
required a dedicated own knowledge, a new body of knowledge is born.
While we used
mathematics, not be consider just a tool, where mathematics has to answer their
own questions independent how is being used, the user of the tool need consider
just a tool for his own purposed. Each epistemology comes from his own set of
question and answering their own, while maybe be related to others, there is complexity,
maybe lost when a single view is being consider.
Many will
consider there one body of knowledge is better than others, which miss the
point, when we consider a body of knowledge, cannot be compare, because the
question is different, so the issue every body of knowledge become their
complexity. One example shows this complexity our evolution of our brains, which
dependent in a localized plasticity.
The plasticity
dependent on actual physical limitation, but to overcome the space a solution,
a hardware solution, evolution, the synapses 3 trillion of them changes, while
the keep a reference point—memory, smell, vision cue or other technique, the
plasticity able to connected to correlated new patterns, what we are, our
strength and our weakness, evolution give such elegant solution, simple and
complex, making an amazing, how life with his own limitation—created a
solution, dependent on the context of
the process where the question is born and encounter.
There is no such
thing one is better than other, all dependent what is the question—understanding,
not to say there is no such thing right or wrong, not unique to any group or
believer group, never do to others, what do not want to you, the question of fairness,
power—how someone defined ownership, who owns the law, how the law set to favor
one group towards others. How property is defined, who benefit, what is individual
committeemen towards the collective—what the collective committeemen to the
individual, what are the relationship.
Science is not a
detached endeavor, is part of collective experience, we can share, dream and
make live better for all of us, no man is Island, we all shared a common experience,
not just our specie, but we trivet in
this evolution, because evolution, the environment was conducive for us to
trivet, we have an obligation to all of us—ourselves to environment who made
life for us possible a better placed, this experienced what make us human
experience, growth all of us, an injury to one, as injury to all of us, we do
not won this world, whether we exist or not the world—with his evolution will
continue, what we are what we make for everyone, and our environment.
We are in cross
roads, the drought in Syria force population to move, forcing a social moment,
but because US involvement in Iraq, the conflict spilled in Syria, and this
forced an emigration which was taken place from Africa, because the corruption,
inequality in Africa move to Europe for a better life, bringing their
individual problems, and with crises in Syria,
the xenophobic groups, encourage and supported by Russia, applying 19
century Russian Imperialism of Russification, now we are ended 2017 with a
delusion this problems will resolved, in case Syria and Iraq carved minorities living side by side, having
different believes, language, traditions and historical grievances are not
going away nothing have change, the long this grievances—differences are
confront and resolved.
The should be an
independent Kurdish state independent what Turkey say—Russia or other nations, sometimes
individuals need to be separated to find their identity and able to deal with
the world around, not as nationalism, but recognition of individual, while
nationalism is based on some historical, ethnic, cultural—believe, individual
recognized in the human-experience.
Wednesday, November 01, 2017
Homo Redux
Biology is very complicated science, the nature of the biology,
sometimes have simple interactions, other times complicated interactions, but
due there is a fundamental interaction
outside, due to the environment, itself , always is complicated, there
is no accident, a tool in Biology is the used of the statistics to explain many
of this complex interactions.
In popular culture the idea intelligence (the question what is intelligence—consciousness,
we can defined to respond intelligence is respond to the interaction and consciousness
is awareness of interaction).
Nature have given two factors driven organic system survival and continuation,
but in the same sentence nature measure the cost, how much energy used to
balance this effort (Israelowitz et al, 2011, Bionic Engr Journal, Vol 8, 129-139; Israelowitz
et al, 2014, New Journal of Science: Biophysics) . Evolution finds many strategies,
before De Waal in Prosocial primates: selfish and unselfish motivations, 2010
rediscover Mutualism, Peter Kropotkins Mutual Aid: A factor of Evolution, first
published in 1902, shows as a strategy, since minimize the energy cost, by
showing co-dependence increased the opportunity for survival of the specie.
Gödel as a responded to Russell and whitehead principia mathematics, connect
where the try to connect logic (a Philosophy discipline) to Mathematics, in
part due misconception the since science is express in mathematics the will be
a unification of knowledge. What Gödel say the long was an internal consistence
in the mathematical stamen will stand, the issue is not stamen ever wills consistence,
the best you can say in so far as known.
This is a limitation to any set of rules, interactions cannot be redux to
set of rules, to just chemistry recipes, evolution strategy is human have 86 billion
neuros (Azevedo et al, 2009. J Comp
Neurol. 2009 Apr 10; 513(5):532-41. doi: 10.1002/cne.21974 ), but what is key
is the 1 trillion of synapses (connections) the reason is plasticity.
If male have stroke and paralysis (https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/stroke/symptoms-causes/syc-20350113),
then due males have two hemisphere disconnected, regaining speech become hard
rod only possible due to plasticity (the synapses making new connections), if
the same event occur to female our species, the biology, female have two the
two hemisphere connected have easy time to repair due to more connections in the
plasticity, what the plasticity due is an evolutionary strategy better
connection, in other hand the more basic interactions chemical level, Charlie
Rose with Kendall in their series about the brain, the schizophrenia deal with
a particular aspect, evolutionary strategy our brain growth 3 times to our 18th
then the brain bring shrinks, at that moment study show the dendrites (pruning where
plasticity is not possible), (https://charlierose.com/collections/3/clip/14403).
Another aspect of evolutionary strategies our early memories for most of
our species begin when seven years old, early memories are suppress, there is correlation
this memories dependent on speech (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memory_development).
As anecdote the sister of Steven Jobs last words was vow, all this connections
shot down, what will be.
Our science dependent allot instrumentation, before analysis can take
place, one criticism of Positron Emission Tomography is show regions, but not
the detail of the plasticity, regions do not show detail of dendrite interaction,
other methods need to be consider (Freedenberg et al, 2014, Performance and Limitations of Positron Emission
Tomography (PET) Scanners for Imaging Very Low Activity Sources, Phys Med. 2014
Feb; 30(1): 10.1016/j.ejmp.2013.04.001), the issue become, the evolution strategy
become in the plasticity, and the question what is minimum connections a
biological system can create awareness.
Part of the Homo Deus redux is the fact mutualism is one best evolutionary
strategy, the economic meltdown 2008, where trust verify was ignore, based on
the illusion the greed is rational, when the Agencies which certified (private)
the bonds, lie and sold junk bonds with excellent certification, and the fact
many this banks take avenge London was the hub for European Union, the US bank
unload this junk bonds to European Union creating the economic meltdown in
European Union.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)