For clarification the author, thinks:
the a two state solution in the 67´s line is necessary, and if the creation of
the two states will resolved the conflict Israeli Palestinian conflict of
course not, but contradiction is more significant and complicated. The conflict
is not just ethnic or religious, but culture conflict. While, nationalism need
to be criticizes and question the Xenophobic elements of any nationalistic
argument, a clear line need to be draw of the creation of the outsider: the other.
Some authors like Gilbert Achar, in his arguments, against the Jews and Israelis,
quite disingenuous and under tones of hate, pure Anti-Semitic, in his book the
Arabs and the Holocaust, arguments:
i)
The
idea of single state, while was not share with Zionist movement, the
alternative was a Binationalist state, exposed
by Martin Buber in 1902, and in 1942, the Binational Party was founded :“Ihud”,
members included members Judah Leon Magnes (Reform rabbi), Akiva Simon
(Educator Philosopher-one of the member founder of the Binational party), Harrieta
Stolz-Founder of Birth-Shalom, the group expose the idea of an Economic Co-federation
with Palestinian Arabs. In the Middle East, example of the ethnic religious and
ethnic conflicts, left mark Lebanon, where the French drafted constitution to
share the power of 4 religious groups,, Between Christian Maorites, Shias,
Sunni and Druzes, the end result has been civil wars, and today the Party of
God Killing the Primate Minister, in some way spelling the Iran and Saudi Conflict.
Syria where the Ba´ath party (in a core Arab Nationalism, one of the Founder a
Christian Michel, Aflaq, turn Marxist applied the theory to Arab-Nationalist,
and propagated the idea of the Arab Genius: while he did not acknowledge the
fact, the Imperial Islam, like any conquest absorbed the creativity of the
vassal, then the test become if the conquer has their own creative, when the
source is dry, and in fact the Islamic rationalist movement of 9 and 10 Century
was marginalize as apostate, a last chance of a rationalist tradition was in AndalucÃa,
but with fundamentalist Berber Islam take-over, disintegrated the Caliph, make
easy to the persistence Christian in Spain Reconquista of the land, conquest by
Islam in the 7 century ), and Syria supported by the minorities Christians, Druses
and other Shia sects, where the Sunni
Majority was open discriminated and Assad shot them out power, where marginalizes
to the small villages and now we are 2 years of civil war, where Iraq is
opposite in the ethnic configuration. Where the Sunni Minority had control of
the power or Pakistan where the Sunni majority killing other minorities Shia
(February 2013, Bombs by Sunni´s just because they are Shias) or Christians
(March 2013, Christian Houses and Churches burn, because rumors of desecration
of the Koran by a Christians), or Egypt where the Christian Coptic (these fears
a well-founded-while many Muslin like to point out the respect for the other
two monotheistic religions, the special laws discriminated, in case of the Coptic’s
for more 1200 years their jobs allot under this laws were what Islam consider degraded
like burring the death, as historical note: the caliphate of Bagdad in the 7
century introduce colors to distinguish the believers, original to target the
Christians Blue and extended to the Jews Yellow, because the Jews share the circumcision
with the Muslim, Jews were required to put a Yellow strip around the waist when
used the public bath) are in fear of imposition of Sharia by Muslin Brotherhood,
but not uniqu to the conflict in Egypt, Tunisia, Libya, the imposition of
Sharia in Mali, or the Algeria Civil conflict between the secular Military and
Islamist decedent to nihilistic, and excommunicated to each other. What Islam
suffers is lack of reformation, Luther introduce the concept, an individual can
interpret the scripture, and individual can have divine inspiration, Islam
fundamental problem is not just a religion, after all the religions by nature discriminated
against non-believers, but Islam like in Judaism is not just a way of living,
but a political solution, Iran and Saudi are examples of their vision, where an
other hand Indonesia, have secular tolerance, the difference Judaism is
local-applied to a group a political solution, where Islam has international messianic
vision.
ii)
The Nationalist vision exposed by the Baáth
party, Nasser in Egypt, Sadan in Iraq, Assad in Syria, of national, socialist,
where the religion is not the common bound, but ethnic, the Arab, Edward Said
in his critique to the west in Orientalism make the philosophical argument, the
imperial west, while not mention Oil, drive the west into oppression, such
example is the CIA overthrowing the prime minister of Iran in the 1950´s for
nationalism the oil, and share the wealth with the population, 20 years after
the CIA implanting the Shah, the Theocratic State has risen, while the critique
of exploitation, and problems is valid, what is not mention Islam has been by
nature founded by the power of the sword. Andrew Wheatcroft in his book The
enemy at Gate, Ottoman try twice to take Vienna, and the reason whatever
economics influence the two ties, a reason was for the Ottoman Empire to show
the power due to their believe of the superiority of Islam. Today, many are trying
to be apologist and give a romantic view of the Spanish Conquest, where conquest
when to French Province, and they stop by the Mountain of North Spain, the reality
is the Christians Visigoth fought back, the Arab Nationalism is product of 19 Century,
like Zionism, of a group feeling alienated, due to economics and ethnic, the
search for an identity, and this identity manifested in national program, where WWI was the place
where this view come to conflict, the Ottoman Empire never forgot they force
created Islam by conquest of Byzantium and enter WWI under the same assumption.
iii)
The
ideal of a combination of Nationalism and Religious, ethnic identity, the Mufti
of Jerusalem (Muhammad Amin al-Husayni), not just charges with crime against
humanity, because he created (helping the SS to recruit and encourage the
recruit) the SS units operated in Balkans and genocide Serbians in Croatia, 13
Mountain SS Unit 90 % where Bosnik, while the Muslin, while Sarajevo, Mostar
and Banja Luka, Ulama (Islamic Cleric) issue a decrees not collaborated with
the Fascist Government. The Mufti of Jerusalem drove personally the recruitment
with translator, who testifies against him in his trial in abstention. The Division
actions operated against Tito, but involved of Killing of Serbians and Jews.
Achar quite disingenuous argument for the Allied about 3,000 Muslin operated with
Allies, Acher will like the 30,000-60,000 operated in open Genocide against the
Serb and Jews should be forgotten (in the 90´s the Serbians used the historical
memory to Genocide Bosnik, the historical grievance come into place), not to
mention the original support to the Fascist Franco regime, where Moroccans-Berbers
against the Left Republic. Whatever, the reason or not, what the Mufti the worst
action: we have children out hope, whether wealthy or the poor, the Mufti personally
was involved in deny twice as mention in the previous blog (Total, 9000
Children try to enter to British Palestine territory).
iv)
The
question in the Koran about 33 Suras are specific against the Jews, and in some
point even the rocks will betray Jews hidden place, the reason, when Mohammad
after her prophetic delusion, being in the Cave in Saudi Peninsula, he enter
the heaven through Jews Temple in Jerusalem, he wanted legitimize her fantasy,
not just the Jews refuse, but the fought back against himself and his fantasy,
this was the event, like the Jews refuse to accept the Christian Messiah. Achcar
call the Jews racist because they believe in their special relationship with
God (he bring argument of Anarchist Jew who mention this idea, Achcar is taken
covert, but his prejudice and argument under scrutiny does not stand), this can
be said to any religious believe, but specific, Judaism is a religion, and for
almost 5,000 year interactive with native population. David grant-mother, the
second King of Israel was a Moabite. From here on this issue most need to be handling
careful-the author works with his degree in Applied Mathematics, with Biology is
his specialty for disclosure.
v)
Our
evolution, show our primates ancestor, and our Homo-Sapient originated, somewhere
in today Ethiopia Africa, we all share are common DNA. In 1937 before Nuremberg
Laws took effect, where not inter-marriage between Jews and Arians are allot,
Robert Jay Lifton, in his book the Nazi Doctor: Medical Killing and the Psychology of Genocide, the rational of
the Genocide beginning in the Eugenics movement in the US (at the time, even in
the middle 80´s in the Southern States- old confederation was a crime of mixing
to the races, between African American white), the first genocide is mention by
Richard J Evans, The Third Reich in Power, where genocide began against regime classified,
mental illness and depravation, the genocide began in 1934. The racist argument
against the Jews does not stand, conversions are in fact part of the history of
Judaism, and not up to Napoleon they acquire a legal identity.
vi)
John
Weiss, in his book, in “The Ideology of Death,” mention the a rationalization
for dehumanizing the Jews, and influence Himmler and SS, was the fantasy, the
Arian are from other world and Jews out envy appropriated some fundamental
truths expose by religion Goodrick Clarck in his book , Black Sun: Aryan Cults,
Esoteric Nazism, and the Politics of Identity, dealt how this fantasy had
influence the Neo-Nazi movement, in Italy Julius Evola and South America,
Chile, Miguel Serrano, expose the esoteric, idea, of blood memory, and Germans
is other species, because they created a less species (Jews) who wanted to appropriated
their accomplishment and identity, they superior race, had the right to
genocide.
vii)
A second line argument to dehumanize the Jews,
because the archeological founded from the death sea scrolls to excavations
Mendigo, the question of a historical claim. Genetic studies have been used Human
Populations, we need to be careful, Genes are not predisposition or indication
or prediction of behavior, biology is a very complex science, sometimes consist
of simple rules, sometimes very complex, but any interaction is always very
complex. Genetic studies are used for study of sickness of certain groups,
Iceland has been one of this group (because our limited understanding, the
models consider small population to understand the basic), because Icelandic relative
isolation is ideal for genetic studies, more specific, a clan (group sharing
same genetic material) in Colombia, of 5,000 people decent of a Basque family which,
settle in 17000s, 50% of the clan carry the Alzheimer’s gene.
viii)
The
study of Human population genetics, in general consider, the mitochondrial
contain 37 Genes and past from female to female (mitochondria is the maternal
gene-the mitochondria is found in bacteria- Lynn Margulis at University of
Massachutsetts, Amherst, the endosymbiotic hypothesis) does not have a
variation. The second line is the Y chromosome, a recent study by Menez et al,
2013, in American Journal Human genetics 93, show human line is about 338,000
years. This method have been used to study, in case of the priest class 6 Y –STR
markers, in general we carry 46 chromosome, 23 from each parent, Y from the
male and X from the female, for the male case. X from the male and X female for
the female case, the studies began in
1997 by Skorecki et al, Nature, 1997, 385:32, later study Thomas MG et al 1998,
Nature 394:138-140. While in “001 Zoossmann et al, Journal Cooperative Human
Biology 51: 156-162, said the evince over state, but in 2005 Enkis in the ASGH
meeting found the markets in 1997 study did not overstated, moreover in 2005,
Felsenstein at University Washington (Professor Computer Science and Statistic)
developed a map of the population and Behar et al, 2004, presented results of
unique haplotype tree, the 21 Jewish Priest family and the common ancestor is about 2400 with a
margin error of plus and minus 300 years. Most of the genetic studies for the
Jews base on the mitochondrial studies, Osther in 2012 in his book Legacy: A Genetic
History Jewish People summarize the studies so far. The theory the Ashkenazi
Jews are decent of the Turkish tribe of the Kazahrs. Judah Halevi in Book Kuzari tell story of the
King of the Kazhars conversion in the 1976, Arthur Koestler propose the thesis
the Ashkenazi Jews descendent from the Khazars, the rational because how is
possible the exist such large population, in
2005 Nabel (Christian Albrecht University of Kiel, and work was
conducted in the University of Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa) et al, European Journal Human Genetics
13: 388-391, based on the Y chromosome polymorphic the Ashkenazim Jews related
to Sephardic Jews and Middle East, but 12 % of the Ashkenazi have R-M17
halogroup is also found at moderated high frequency in central Asia. In 2013,
Study from Baltimore try to show Ashkenazi Jews are sole decent, study methodology
did not consider the actual Kazhar (Groups is still found in Central Asia).
The myth of Anti-Semitism
is base in desire to deny any legitimize the Jews, because is Amon Oz, what I
want they want also, for Religious or ethnic desire, for political reason, they
want to demonized the Jews, the reason, legitimize to a God.
Achcar want the Jews to
said had not special relationship to God, so Islam have this privilege and left,
they forgot was the Soviet Union made the pact with National Socialist Germany,
they lost any credibility, and 60 year after the pact, the system disintegrated.
The central state left
in Cuba (the system is changes cannot survive in long run), China (the state
capitalism), North Korea (Leader Cult), while Islam own fantasies in Iran under
though sanctions cannot survived.
